Showing posts with label gdp. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gdp. Show all posts

Wednesday, 16 November 2011

Kyle Bass on European Debt Restructuring

The most important point of this video comes between 5:15 and 6:00.





The more important point from the point of energy is this:


There is NO way that oil production can grow at the speed required by the world credit market interest rate payments to be covered by real (non-financial) economic growth.

As Jim Puplava put it: Brent oil barrel price is the new global and automatically rising federal funds rate. It will cut off all economic growth every time it goes above $120-$140 / barrel (in c. 2008 dollars, as you have to keep  inflation in mind).

The world economy is toast. There is no way around it.

No amount of extra credit can solve this.

Only debt restructuring (i.e. default) will solve the economic issue.

The limited flow rate of energy guarantees that no other options is available.

And the more this issue is pushed into the future with temporary emergency measures, the bigger the debt that has to be written down will be and the faster the oil flow rate decline will be (it's increasing day by day).

And thus, harder the landing.

Brace yourself for impact in this slow-motion train wreck and try to position yourself to the last cart on the train.

Sunday, 27 February 2011

Why The Economist doesn't understand energy

The following image is from The Economist which argues that the use of energy is being reduced as measured by Energy intensity of the economy (percentage of GDP).


An astute reader of energy physics and economics should understand the obvious failings of the above diagram for any argument about energy intensity of economies:


  1. The graph measures energy use per GDP unit, whilst including all of the financial GDP. However, financial GDP is pure speculative money, consuming very little energy, but also contributing very little to society. Further, using USA as a proxy for most OECD countries, financialization of the economy has been growing steadily for several decades now. It should be cleaned from the GDP to get a more meaningful measure of 'energy use per unit of GDP in the real productive economy'.
  2. The energy consumption is based on figures from BP, which does not account for grey energy imports. Grey energy imports have been rising for all OECD and lately even for developing countries. They can account for up to 25% to 30% of total energy consumption. If not included, the figures can be seriously skewed, especially for developed industrial countries within the OECD.
  3. The correction to GDP figures (PPI 2009 level) has probably been done using CPI figures. We know from energy consumption figures, growth of monetary aggregates  and statistical corrections done in the CPI calculations (i.e. hedonistics) that these figures are unreliable: they are likely to understate the inflation, thus overstating economic growth in real terms.


However, the most obvious and glaring misuse of the following graph to argument in favour of energy not being a problem for economic growth is thinking that GDP growth solves energy consumption growth. Make no mistake, absolute energy consumption is and has been going up (the only exception years being those of deep recessions). The energy consumption growth has just been relatively slower than the skewed GDP figures The Economist used above.

After all these minor statistical quibbles, the main problem is not the relative scarcity of energy sources to economic growth, but absolute consumption growth and absolute limits. Anybody with a half an hour's worth of reading in ecological economics should understand this immediately.

If energy consumption per capita as a % of GDP was the only problem, then we could avoid the rolling energy crisis by nationalizing everything and raising hourly wages for everyone by controlling prices. This would show up as increased GDP, near zero inflation and the amount of relative energy consumption to GDP would to go down.

That’s the theory anyway, if one is stupid enough to believe the misleading propaganda from The Economist.

Think for yourself. There is no substitute for it.

Wednesday, 25 November 2009

Some assorted Oil Graphs

What happens if we have to use too much of our money to buy oil?


What happens to oil decline rate if peak comes later?


Why does the price of oil keep going up?

Where is the expected oil demand growth going to come from?

What happens to oil price as oil production spare capacity shrinks?


What happens to oil demand in the greatest recession?


Sometimes a picture - even not so good one - is worth a thousand words. So, let's try some:

Friday, 26 January 2007

Energy = GDP

From Anthropik (slightly modified):



Remember, it's energy that matters, not capital. You can't burn money, if you are short on energy. Or actually you can burn paper notes, but you can't run an economy on them. Way too low energy density, bad EROEI and non-renewable.