Tuesday, 15 May 2007

Is algae bio-diesel (also) a fool's gold?



Everybody loves to hate 1st generation biofuels these days. Inefficient, polluting, do not scale well and net energy losers. In short: totally useless waste of money and energy in terms of energy production. Very useful for political gains though.

Now, some people are more optimistic about 2nd generation biofuels, esp. cellulosic ethanol and similar processes from plant based feed. However, serious doubts have been cast on their sustainability as well (economic, ecological and net energy wise).

The greatest hope has been given to algal biodiesel. It has been touted as the fastest growing (scaling), least energy input and best fuel output biofuel type. It was supposed to become an explosive growth area and solve our biofuel scaling problems.

Up until now.

Two posts, referencing some of the most realistic studies in the field, cast a really big shadow over algal biodiesel.

A direct quotes from Dr. Krassen Dimitrov's paper:

"Fundamental thermodynamic constrains make it impossible for such approach to be commercially viable for fuel prices below $800/bbl, even if flawless technological implementation is assumed." (emphasis added)

"A PBR-based biodiesel plant will have a maximum carbon mitigation potential of less than 30 kgCO2/m2/yr" (read: miniscule, emphasis)

"Biofuel production in PBR-based plants compares unfavourably with other alternative technologies for liquid fuel production, carbon mitigation and solar energy." (emphasis added)
This is not to say that biofuels from algae are not currently among our best bad hopes for biofuels replacing fossil fuels. It's still the best scaling and apparently best net energy ratio biofuel out there. Both currently and in theoretical improvements. (If somebody is thinking CTL, yes it's a probability for non-biofuel alternatives, but the ghg emissions are not pretty compared even to gasoline).

Algal bio-diesel is just not enough.

Nothing known scales to 85 million barrels of use per day. Not even 1/10 of that. It is just not physically possible to grow that amount of biofuel. The land area, energy inputs and logistics do not make sense. Thus, the economic does not make sense either.

Still, algal biofuels will be made, will be improved and I'm betting there'll be an investment bubble around them, just as there's one now around bio-ethanol (1st gen), which is more or less complete bogus.

If you are an investor, you have been warned: don't try to break physics with an investment plan.

Friday, 11 May 2007

Oil & Energy in the world - a month or so in review

Just another month? Perhaps, perhaps not.

A lot of interesting things have happened in the previous month.

Of course, this is all old new to those who have been following any of the usual suspect sites during the past months. The picture is unfolding almost like the overall script dictates: shortages, deniel, more peaks, price rises, speculation, asset bubbles & resource grabbing.

Now the information is being legitimized and published in wider circulation. More people will read it. More people will start writing blogs, discussing and piecing information together. More news on the issue. Definitely papers and politicizing on the issue.

Out of all the noise of news, a picture is starting to emerge. Let's try an exercise, one of many optional pictures:
  1. The energy market as a whole has overheated, following the similar trends on various asset markets. Biofuel markets are slowly merging with food markets, with important consequences
  2. Oil demand growth is still too strong, supply is limited and near future is even more uncertain. Prices are likely to rise, even without supply disruptions (Nigeria, Iraq, etc.) and natural disasters (hurricanes hitting refineries)
  3. Future of worldwide supplies compared to demand is starting to come under serious doubt. Nobody has publicly shown numbers to convince the numbers people that production can scale to projected need.
  4. Future energy replacements for oil (nuclear, biofuels, coal, syn-crude, natgas) are looking less optimistic (scaling, sustainability, energy, carbon offsets). This includes the most optimistic of current biofuels: algae based bio-diesel. The rest, including corn ethanol, is mostly an expensive smokescreen.
  5. The positive feedbacks in the system are getting easier to spot: prices spiraling up -> dash for deep water oil resources -> shortage of equipment and people in oil services sector -> more investments in alternatives -> more hyping of alternatives & new (small) oil discoveries -> more clouding of the fundamentals of flow rates, reserve replenishment and demand growth
  6. Global Warming still reigns supreme as the topmost important topic of our time, but the connection between the two is still rarely made. Everybody seems to assume coal ihas to be gone, but the amount of commissioned plants being built is increasing, not decreasing.
  7. People, politicians and markets are becoming more nervous about the energy issues, especially the price, but still seem to believe that delivery is guaranteed.
If one combines the slow realisation of the above factors (true or not, with timing uncertainty) with the current economic situation, the combined picture doesn't look overly optimistic.

Are we heading for global energy demand destruction via a combination of price increases and slower economic growth?

Right now, with the data available, it sure does look like it.

Monday, 7 May 2007

Review: Heat - How to Stop the Planet from Burning (Monbiot)



George Monbiot has written a fairly ambitious book, "Heat - How to Stop the Planet from Burning". It tries to show through simple arithmetic and several examples, how UK as a country of example could cut it's carbon emissions to 10% by 2030.

That is a 90% cut in emissions.

Stop and think about it for a while. That is a huge cut and not easily implemented.

George Monbiot is not easily daunted however and he puts on a good effort. He details ways to cut emissions in parts of industry, in homes and in various methods transport. The examples are many, calculations simple enough to understand for any reader and arguments mostly convincing. The book doesn't even fall to the over optimistic trap by claiming anything is possible. In fact, it details even more in which methods will not help us reach the goal of 90% emission cuts. Realism is always a needed virtue for anybody who tries to achieve the near impossible.

The book also tries to instill the reader with a sense of hope and urgency, with the balance tipping more to the side of hope. Yes, we can do it. Yes, the cuts will be enormous in scale. Yes, modern way of life (esp. tourism and world goods trade) as we know it, will not be the same if we pull off the required cuts. But we can do it.

It does have major omissions, like only mentioning peak oil, net energy and scaling of alternatives very broadly. Recently the author has also stated that he thinks peak oil is fairly far off and as due to technological advancements not a major problem. Unfortunately, he isn't clearly as read on the oil issue as he seems to be with carbon emission cuts. The climatologist superstar James Hansen has suggested that peak oil may not be a disaster in regards to carbon emissions, if we do not start burning massive amounts of coal to replace the oil with. And burning lots of dirty coal is exactly what we are planning to do. This is a major issue and could completely undermine most of the other savings dealt with in the book.

On the positive side the book even deals with Khazzoom-Brookes postulate and Jevons paradox, which is rare for a book that tries to encourage efficiency increases. On this issue Monbiot is also wisely cautious: not all efficiency increases result in overall reduction (of energy or resources). In fact, it may often be the case that on the macro-scale of things, it results in overall increase of usage.

Even with the net energy and peak energy omissions, the book has another - even bigger omission. And this is a big omission.

The book falls short on the most important factor dealing with the question "how?"

How do we actually implement:

  1. Major legislative overhaul in housing, construction, energy, transport, taxation and subsidies
  2. Almost complete restructuring of our transport systems (cars, roads, rail, air travel, etc.)
  3. Major revolution in housing construction and renovation (esp. design, heating & insulation)
  4. Huge changes in electricity production and end-use efficiency along with grid overhaul
  5. A transition to a culture less dependent on consumption growth: one that is less materially and energy intensive
  6. Almost complete replacement of hydrocarbons (gas, oil and esp. coal) with pure and efficient renewable energy sources and alternative liquid fuels that are sustainable both in net energy and emission calculation
... when the actors able to influence these things are:
  1. Politicians who pontificate with each other and put out study papers one after another and make wonderful excuses about why most measures are too drastic and should not be implemented (at least not in their term)
  2. Companies who only claim to provide what the consumers want and oppose almost all new legislations aiming for higher efficiency, less carbon emissions or higher costs for emissions
  3. Consumers, who want to consume more for less and think it is the job of the companies and the politicians to get us out of this mess
That is the ultimate challenge. The world is not short on methods or current technologies.

Monbiot bows out of this discussion by saying that it is us, the readers of this book, who have to come up with the way to make things happen. The methods and technologies are there (according to his research), now we need just the economic and political will to do it.

In a sense he is right. We can only demand things from others, if we do it ourselves. So, let's start (paraphrasing from the book and from other sources):
  • re-insulate our houses, change the boilers and install a heat-exchange capture in the ventilation house
  • stop using a personal car 90% of the time: walk, bike and use the public transport
  • stop flying
  • start buying seasonal, locally produced and preferably organic food (buy & eat it fresh, don't refrigerate)
  • stop eating beef, pork & poultry (a bit of fish and game may be allowed, otherwise a vegetarian diet)
  • start family planning (perhaps already unintentionally overdone in most OECD countries)
  • shop only what you need (not what you want), shop it locally, shop 2nd hand goods, use mail order if you have to shop from afar (don't drive there yourself) and buy services and goods with low energy/emission impact (how to identify these is a real dilemma)
  • if you run a company, redesign it's whole material and energy flows and restructure the whole process (TPS & VSM are a good place to start, but you can't stop there)
  • if you are a politician: legislate, tax and set up consumer and company incentives. That is, make it possible and required to aim for the cuts. And oh yes, stop going to war for oil and natural gas. Make cuts your primary goal and everything subject to that, even if it makes you unpopular and risks re-election.
If we do all that and succeed with a 60-90% efficiency - worldwide - then yes, we might be able to stop the planet from burning. Nobody really knows for sure. The models just aren't that accurate to tell with certainty.

And even if you don't believe in anthropogenic global warming, there are other equally compelling reasons to start implementing the above measures.

So, the task is daunting and it is meant for everyone of us.

And no, you can't buy your way out of flying restriction through carbon offsets. They just do not work well enough (read the book to if you really need to find out why). And no, techno-fixes are not a solution either, but more like aching to believing in the second coming of Christ - perhaps useful if you are able to abandon reasonable principle of precaution, current scientific knowledge and can wait a couple of thousand years. And if you are still guaranteed a reserved seat in the paradise if all goes to hell in a hand basket.

And that, in short, is the main failing of the book and most likely us, the readers.



The task may be just too daunting, too painful, too requiring in synchronicity of action and mass enlightenment to be able to be pulled off.

A more apt title for the book would have been "Heat - How we could stop the planet from burning, but probably won't because we are too lazy and complacent to really do anything about it, until it's probably too late". Then again, maybe the would have run out of cover space for that one.

Still, the book should be recommend heartily as it does offer hope and a summary of methods, required you can look past the omissions. But you don't really need to buy and read the book. You can start to cut your own emissions today. In fact, you can make the first cut by not buying the book. It's a small thing, but it's a start. After that, all you need is to continue with the cuts.

Just don't get complacent and don't let the rest of us do that either.


Obligatory FAQ: What does this have to do with energy? All anthropogenic carbon emissions are a direct result of consuming energy, especially fossil fuels like oil. When you cut your oil use, you not only make your life more resilient to oil shocks, but also cut carbon emissions.

Sunday, 15 April 2007

[FIN] - Yksi hyvä syy miettiä energiaa



Energia noudattaa erilaisia lakeja kuin monet muut ilmiöt, joihin nykyajan ihmiset ovat tottuneet. Nykyisin ihmiset ovat tottuneet ajattelemaan esimerkiksi seuraavankaltaisilla malleilla:

Yllä olevissa käsitteissä ja niiden ympärille muodostuneissa hokemissa on varmasti sosiaalisessa keskustelussa oma järkensä: puhutaan jaetulla ymmärryksellä, niin kukaan ei loukkaannu, eikä synny turhaa kinaa. Eikä tarvitse vaivautua kaivamaan esiin faktoja tai oppimaan lainalaisuuksia, jotka ovat järkkymättömiä.

Energia puolestaan noudattaa perustavanlaatuisia fysiikan lakeja. Nämä eivät ole valinnanvaraisia tai mielipidekysymyksiä. Ne ovat. Mikäli haluaa keskustella edes suunnilleen järkevästi, lukijan on mukauduttava näihin lakeihin, eikä mukautettava niitä omien mielipiteidensä mukaisiksi. Tällöin keskustelu energiasta olisi sopusoinnussa tunnettujen lakien kanssa.

Näin kuitenkaan harvoin käy yleisessä keskustelussa. Ihmisillä on mitä erilaisempia näkemyksiä energiasta, usein ilman minkäänlaisia faktoja tai vastaavuutta fysiikan lakien kanssa.

Otetaanpa muutama esimerkki. Suomalaisten tietokoneharrastajien foorumissa, MBNetissä, julkaistiin pieni keskustelunavaus öljyriippuvuudesta ja linkitettiin tämän blogin yhteen viestiin.

Uutinen itsessään oli hyvä. Useimmat kommentit sen sijaan osoittivat, mikä on energiaymmärryksen taso suomalaisten keskuudessa. Tietenkään yhden nettikeskustelun kommenttiketjusta ei voi vetää tilastollisesti päteviä johtopäätöksiä. Silti ketjun kommenttien sisältö vastaa hyvin omaa käsitystäni yleistä keskustelua, mukaan lukien eturivin poliitikkojen ja useiden elinkeinoelämän päättäjien kommentit aiheesta.

Energiasta on tullut niin itsestään selvää ja näkymätöntä, että siitä ei osata puhua sen tarvitsemin käsittein tai analysoida totuudenmukaisesti. Riittää kun on joku mielipide, kuten "inhoan/puolustan ydinvoimaa" tai jotain muuta tunteellista, joka sopii omaan elämäntyyliin.

Käymättä läpi jokaista viestiä erikseen, kommentit voidaan jakaa muutamaan kategoriseen virhepäätelmäluokkaan, joita voi kutakin tarkastella joukkona:

  • "Uusia energianlähteitä voi keksiä [tyhjästä korvaamaan öljyä]"
    Tämä on mahdotonta, koska se rikkoo termodynamiikan ensimmäistä pääsääntöä.
  • "Öljyn voi korvata sähköllä"
    Sähkö ja öljy eivät ole keskenään vaihtokelpoisia. Öljy on primäärienergian lähde. Sähkö on energiavektori (energian kuljettaja). Niitä ei voi edes käsitellä samalla tavoin fysikaalisissa laskutoimituksissa, ellei osaa rajoittaa laskutoimitusten päättelysoveltuvuutta rankasti. Sähkö tuotetaan aina primäärienergian kiinteistä lähteistä tai vuosta (virtaus, kuten auringon säteily). Käytännön esimerkki vaihtokelpoisuuden puutteesta: sähköä ei voi kaataa bensatankkiin. Sähköstä ei voi tehdä muovia tai muita petrokemian tuotteita.
  • "Öljyn voi korvata biomassalla tai sen jalosteilla"
    Mitään tunnettua biomassaa ei pystytä tuottamaan päivässä 86 miljoonan öljytynnyrin sisältämän energiamäärän verran. Teoriassa tämä olisi mahdollista, jos käytössä olisi enemmän kasteluvettä kuin nyt, energiatasolla ilmaiset lannoitteet, jalostushyötysuhteeltaan 100% valmistusprosessi ja useita kymmeniä kertoja nykyisen verran viljelykelpoista maapinta-alaa. Mitään näistä ei kuitenkaan ole olemassa, eikä niitä voi tehdä tyhjästä tai ratkaista teknologialla, paitsi taloustieteilijöiden kuvitelmissa – rikkomalla samalla fysiikan lakeja.
  • "Tuuli- ja aurinkovoima on hyödytöntä näpertelyä"
    Tuulivoiman investoinnin takaisinmaksuaika on tämän hetken energiatuotantolaitoksista nopein. Se on myös riittävän tehokasta tuottamaan järkevää kestävää energiaa (selkeästi positiivinen energiatase). Aurinkovoima ei ole vielä yhtä pitkällä, mutta tuotantoon tulossa olevat ratkaisut nostanevat sen nykyisen tuulivoiman luokkaan lähivuosina. Silti, vaikka molemmat energiamuodot kymmenkertaistaisi Suomessa ja kaiken öljynkulutuksen saisi korvattua sähköllä ja bioraaka-aineilla infrastruktuurimuutoksen kautta, vaihtoehtoiset energiat eivät riittäisi korvaamaan edes nykyistä öljynkulutusta. Vaihtoehtoiset eivät ole hyödytöntä näpertelyä, vaan useiden asiantuntijoiden mukaan osa sitä energiapalettia, johon meidän on pakko siirtyä, jos haluamme ylläpitää jossain määrin saman elintason kuin nyt. Vaihtoehtoja siis tarvitaan, mutta ne eivät yksin riitä.
  • "Öljyn voi korvata helposti energiavaihtoehdolla Y [Y tässä voi olla mikä tahansa]"
    Öljyä ehkä voi korvata täysin millään energiavaihtoehtojen yhdistelmällä, ei ainakaan helposti tai nopeasti. Robert Hirschin tutkimus osoittaa, että öljyhuippuun varautuminen edellyttäisi vähintään 20 vuoden erittäin tehokasta muutostyötä kaikissa liikenteen ja energiateollisuuden perusrakenteissa. Tällöin olisi mahdollista, että ehkä olisi mahdollista selviytyä vähenevästä öljystä ilman merkittäviä katastrofiriskejä. Tällöinkään ei öljyä korvattaisi täysin, vaan ainoastaan osittain. Käytännössä: kuvittele korvaavasi kaikki autot, lentokoneet, laivat, rekat, aggregaatit, muovi- ja lannoitetehtaat uusilla vaihtoehdoilla, jotka käyttävät sähköä, eivätkä öljyä.
  • "Pienen Suomen teoilla ei ole mitään merkitystä, kun X käyttää niin paljon enemmän"
    Tämä on klassinen osittamisesta syntyvä vertailuvirhe, jossa ajatellaan omat teot merkityksettömiksi suureen massaan nähden. Samaa logiikkaa käyttäen voisi todeta seuraavaa: Pohjoismaiden kulutuksella ei ole merkitystä EU:n kulutukseen nähden. EU:n kulutuksella ei ole merkitystä kaikkiin OECD maihin verrattuna. OECD maiden kulutuksella ei ole merkitystä, kun lasketaan koko maailman kasvava kulutus ja erityisesti Aasian kasvava kysyntä. Simbsalabim! Näin tuli juuri perustelluksi, että kenenkään ei tarvitse tehdä yhtään mitään, vaan niiden muiden tulisi tehdä kaikki hankalat päätökset ja teot. Tällaisesta päättelyä kutsutaan yleensä myös virheelliseksi kaltevaksi pinnaksi.
  • "Vety[kennot] korvaa öljyn"
    Vety ei ole maapalolla vapaasti esiintyvä energianlähde, vaan potentiaalinen energiasäilö. Vetyä täytyy irrottaa muista aineista, kuten vedestä ja tallentaa johonkin säiliöön, kuten vetykennoon. Koko vetyprosessi on toistaiseksi kokonaishyötysuhteeltaan noin puolet vastaavan sähköakkujärjestelmän hyötysuhteesta. Lyhyesti sanottuna: vety on energian tehokkaan käytön näkökulmasta hölmöläisten hommaa, eikä ainakaan ratkaisu mihinkään energiapulaan. Energiapulassa tarvitaan pääasiassa uusia energian lähteitä, eikä ainakaan nykyisiä huonompia energiavektoreita, jotka hukkaavat lisää energiaa.

Jos uskoo, että yllä olevat ajatukset energiasta ja öljystä ovat yleisiä ja että ne ovat virheellisiä, kuten yllä on esitetty, niin kysymys kuuluu: miksi?


Miksi emme yritä ymmärtää energiaa? Miksi emme tajua sen merkitystä? Miksi emme osaa analysoida ja laskea sitä? Miksi energia ei ole kiinnostavaa? Miksi sitä ei opeteta koulussa?

Vastaus löytynee tämän viestin ensimmäisestä listasta. Emme ole kiinnostuneita energiasta, koska sitä on ollut käytettävissä viimeisen sadan vuoden ajan joka päivä enemmän kuin eilen. Olemme yhä enemmän kiinnostuneita siitä, mitä energian avulla saadaan aikaan: vauraudesta, teknologiasta, muodista, viihteestä, postmodernista totuusfilosofiasta ja hyvinvoinnista yleisesti.

Ilman halpaa, helppokäyttöistä ja tasaisesti kasvavaa energiavirtaa nykyinen hyvinvointi ei kuitenkaan ole mahdollista. Öljy on vain yksi tämän energian lähteistä, mutta yhdessä kaikki uusiutumattomat fossiiliset polttoaineet kattavat 95% koko maailman energiankulutuksesta. Kun näiden energialähteiden päivittäinen saatavuus heikkenee, heikkenee myös mahdollisuus ylläpitää nykyistä hyvinvointia sen kaikissa ilmenemismuodoissaan.

Siinä on yksi erittäin hyvä syy miettiä ja ymmärtää energiaa.

Saturday, 7 April 2007

Peak Oil - from Obscurity to Public Debate



Currently Peak Oil is pretty much a niche news item on the large scheme of thing. It's getting buried under other big news issues. Not many people are aware of it, or even if they are, they mostly ignore it for various reasons. What is on people's minds and on the media is Global Warming (see graph above for a relative blog exposure of the two phenomenon).

However, it seems like that is about to change...

Forecasting is difficult. Nobody has a crystal ball into psychological events, although physical reality is to some extent within the boundaries of rough forecasts.

However, with that said, here's a forecast:

Peak oil is about to become real to the masses. In a big way. Think this year, maybe during summer already.

The signs are in the air:

All that in the last two weeks alone. It's getting increasingly hard to stay on top of the news. The amount of reporting is growing almost exponentially.

Regardless of whether the estimates of date of peaking are correct, the amount of signal in peak oil discussion is going up and it's reaching more and more mainstream media.

The deniers are getting either more vocal or starting to do a reversal ("yes, there is a peak and it's coming").

Watershed moment in peak oil awareness is approaching. Let's hope the actual peak oil is not yet as close.

When that happens, expect to see the discussion get really muddy. We will move even more from fact based discussion to emotional and argumentative discussion. People will either choose to believe it or not, facts be damned. Some will deny being part of it ("doesn't concern me, I don't drive that much and I don't have a SUV"), while some will just see echoes of history ("Ah, we went through this in the 70s and came out alright on the other side").

In short, the discussion will get more wide, but also the facts are more likely to get lost in all the noise. This will also mean a lot more procrastinating, doing studies, evaluating and huge amounts of lobbying.

And what will be missed by most people in the beginning is that the two discussion (GW + PO) are inexplicably linked. Global warming is almost a direct result of burning hydrocarbons (mostly coal, but also huge amounts of oil and natural gas). What is even more important is what will the world turn to, once it runs out of oil? Coal.

At that point the link between oil production peak and global warming risks will become painfully obvious.

Thursday, 29 March 2007

[FIN] Öljyhuippu ja liikenne Suomessa

Suomen tilanne on viime aikoina tuottanut kasan kysymyksiä:

  • kuinka alttiita ovat eri sektorit öljyn hinta- ja jakeluhäiriöille?
  • kuinka helposti nestemäisiä polttoaineita on korvattavissa?
  • mikä on öljyn hätävaraston koko?
  • missä kulkee öljyn hinnan kipuraja Suomen taloudelle? Entä maailmantaloudelle (jonka osa Suomi on)?
  • kuinka hyödyllisiä ovat esim. Yhdysvaltojen ja muiden maiden vastaavat riskianalyysit ja arviot öljyhuipun vaikutuksista erityisesti juuri liikenteelle?
Näitä kysymyksiä miettiessäni päätin tehdä pari graafia. Tässä ensimmäinen, joka kuvaa Suomen primäärienergian lähteiden kulutusta ja kuinka se jakautuu sektoreittain.




Vasen puoli kuvaa primäärilähteitä ja kuinka niiden osuudet prosenteissa jakautuvat eri sektoreille oikealla puolella kuvaa.

Oikea puoli kuvaa kuluttavia sektoreita ja kuinka paljon niiden energiakäytöstä tulee kustakin primäärilähteestä.

Luvut ovat muuten vuosien 2003-2005 keskiarvoja, jotta erityisesti hiilen vuosikohtaisia heilahteluja on saatu hieman tasattua. Hiili kun tuntuu toimivan erit. yritysten sähkönkäytön tarpeen heiluritekijänä tietyissä markkinatilanteissa, minkä takia kulutus vuodesta toiseen voi vaihdella suuresti, vaikka pitkän välin trendi on aika vakaa.

Mitä kaaviosta voi sitten päätellä? No ei vielä kovin paljoa muuta kuin: liikenne on täysin öljystä riippuvaista. Vaihtoehtoja ei käytännössä ole samassa mittakaavassa. Myös talonsa puhtaasti öljyllä lämmittävien kotien riippuvuus on luonnollisesti suurta, vaikka kokonaisuutena kotitaloussektori ei ole suoraan niin riippuvainen öljystä. Toki välillisesti sekin on äärimmäisen riippuvainen, mm. maataloustuotannon ja kulutushyödykkeiden kautta.

Seuraavaksi olisi tarkoitus tarkastella juuri maatalouden öljyintensiteettiä ja riippuvuuden kehitystä viime vuosikymmenillä, mikäli vain sopiva datajoukko löytyy jostain.

Thursday, 8 March 2007

US Oil : Whither Middle East - Welcome Africa

Recently found Ghadames oil Basin shared by Algeria, Tunisia and Libya
(C) Image courtesy of Rigzone 2007

It is possible that KSA is in terminal decline for it's oil production. Mexico quite certainly is in terminal decline (due to Cantarell oil field crashing). USA imports a lot of it's oil from these two regions.

Where does it go for alternatives? Why does the rest of the world need to even care?

Because where US goes, a trail of bodies follow.

That place is now increasingly Africa. Africa has overtaken Middle East as USA's top oil sourcing region, all without big fanfare. It is of course nothing new, as US has been in African oil producing countries for decades: financing coups, funding insurgencies and corrupting officials. However, not until late last year did Pentagon found AfriCom, which underlines the importance of the continent for US interests.

Currently US is already well entrenched in various African oil countries:

The list of countries targeted for further activities are all oil countries:
  • Equatorial Guinea. UK already tried a coup there in 2003-2004 by using an SAS office (and allegedly financed by son of Margaret Thatcher of all people)
  • Sao Tome & Principe. Has been fairly stable, if not a model state, but has now been rumored to be sliding into further unrest and perhaps into civil war, because commercially viable amounts of oil is being produced there by US companies
  • Algeria. Already on Rumsfeld's hit list of countries to be attacked. Their crime? Sitting on top of a sizable new oil reserve that recently surfaced in public. Unfortunately oil does not follow national borders, so Ghadames Basin is shared by Algeria, Tunisia and Libya. Expect to see a lot of IMF/World bank convoys, Rice visits and additional American troops there "securing freedom and democracy."
  • Sudan (esp. Darfur). Sudan has oil too, but isn't letting US or even UN into their country, so US and its allies attack them black propaganda campaign to justify intervention. Not that there isn't a crisis in Sudan, but the motivation to get into Darfur is surely not humanitarian intervention. It's preventing China from taking all the oil.
The lesson in all this?

If you got it, we will take it. We being not only US, but depending on situation UK, France, China, Russia and a handful of multinational oil corps.

Not only because oil is vital for transport, but because US wants to ensure their economic and military position against the rest of the world, especially towards China and even Russia (and vice versa).

From US pov this is part of the new American century, which includes ensuring US dollar remains as the default reserve currency, especially through oil trade. In plain English: letting the rest of the world finance US debt driven spending which in normal fiscal terms would have been labeled bankrupt a long time ago.

So, if you have plentiful natural resources on which the super powers are dependent on, you are cursed for life, unless you are able to make shrewd deals like the House of Saudi was. Or if you possess nukes, after which you gain additional bargaining chip.

Resource curse is a real thing. It's just not understood by most economists, who tout the market fundamentalism fallacy and believe that free markets really operate in strategically important commodities, such as oil.

So, oil is more than just about keeping the wheels turning literally. It's about geo-strategic domination and economic power over other nations. In this great game, might makes right.

And if you think you as an European (or other non-American industrialized nation) citizen can wash your hands from this, then by all means do, but please stop consuming oil first. Current global trade, price of oil and much of the power of the financial markets rests on the ongoing exploitation of poor oil producing nations by the rich oil consuming nations.

We have blood and oil on our hands, even if we didn't pull the trigger or activate the pump ourselves.

The question for us to ask ourselves is: do we want this to continue and will we allow it?

Friday, 2 March 2007

Oil Peak & Re-distribution of Oil Consumption

Fact 1: World total combined (all liquids) oil production has plateaued since early 2005 at c. 85 million barrels per day (std. dev. c. 1%).

Fact 2: Since then, oil consumption has grown in China, India, and OECD

Fact 3: Spare capacity (difference between production-consumption) has shrunk considerably (page 15, fig. 5).

Question 1: If production has remained steady, there has been very little spare capacity and still some countries have increased their consumption, what else must have happened?

Answer 1: Other countries have had to cut down on their use. This means mostly African countries, which are facing blackouts and energy riots. Even big oil producers like Iran are no strangers to oil rationing.

Answer 2: Oil exports also have to be declining for some countries, even if their production has not, IF their own consumption has been increasing. This is in fact what has been happening in Russia.

Now, regardless of whether we are at all time peak in production or not is beyond the scope of this post. What is interesting is, how will the remaining oil be divided up, once all spare capacity is gone, production starts a decline and consumption is still growing.

The next question is: what will happen next? Will India and China cut their demand growth? How about OECD countries? Answer: not likely.

What other alternatives remain?

It has been said before that poor nations will be hit first and worst by peaking of oil production. The ones that are hanging by a thread in their livelihood and the energy infrastructure of which is most heavily dependent in oil.

Again, this means mostly many African nations, but also the poorer South East Asian nations which huge growing populations and severe oil dependency (Malaysia, Indonesia). Even Mexico is not immune to rising corn prices, driven up by subsidized American bio-fuel producers

The last question remains: will we hear the shout of suffering nations this time around?

Not likely.

What will happen to poorer nations, who are very heavily dependent on oil, import most of their oil used and are already deep in debt (from IMF & World Bank)?

Nobody knows, but the likelihood of seeing several poor countries being labeled "failing states" in the next 10 years and having some form of economic meltdown remains considerable.

If you need more convincing, read the February 2007 Oil Production forecasts post at The Oil Drum.

Wednesday, 21 February 2007

[FIN] Puolueiden energiamielipiteet - vaalikeskustelu YLE TV2 21.2.2007

YLE TV2 lähetti 21.2.2007 keskusteluohjelman, jossa nykyisten eduskuntapuolueiden edustajat saivat kertoa mielipiteistään Suomen energiapolitiikasta.

Ensinnäkin kiitokset ohjelman tekijöille: suoran paskanjauhannan kieltäminen ja aikaisempien historiallisten energiaennustusten virheellisyyden osoittaminen olivat kuin tuore tuulahdus näihin keskusteluihin.

Toiseksi torut lähes kaikille keskustelijoille: jos teiltä pyydetään lyhyttä vastausta tai kysymystä, antakaa sellainen. Tämä pätee erityisesti poliitikkoihin. Teidän tulisi olla puhumisen ammattilaisia. Käyttäytykää sen mukaisesti, vaikka mikrofonin monopolisointi onkin, ah niin houkuttelevaa.

Sitten puolueiden mielipiteisiin, kouluarvosanoin pisteytettynä:

  • Puolue A: "Lisää uusiutuvia, erit. biopolttoaineita, tuulivoimaa, energiansäästöä ja kaiken tämän vero-ohjausta. Kuudetta ydinvoimalaa ei tarvita." Selkeästi perusteltu, perustuen pääosin fysikaaliseen todellisuuteen, ilman että taustalla olisi yhden tahon propagandaa. Ilmastohaaste ymmärretty tärkeänä. Miinus biopolttoaineiden ymmärryksestä.
    Arvosana 8-

  • Puolue B: "Lisää ydinvoimaa, myös kuudes ydinvoimala. Ei näpertelyä ja piperrystä. Silti kuluttajilla on oltava erilaisia vaihtoehjoa. Tuulivoima on kallista. Ei verotusohjaukselle." Äärimmäisen ristiriitainen, täysin vanhentunutta ja tarkoitushakuisesti valittua tilasodataa, poliittisen lipevä ja kaikkia osapuolia nuoleskeleva näkemys. Usko markkinoiden kaikkivoipaisuuteen, mikä on erityisesti energiamarkkinoilla osoitettu historiallisesti täysin virheelliseksi.
    Arvosana: 6-

  • Puolue C: "Ydinvoimaa ja biopolttoaineita, erityisesti maaseudulla. Ei tuulivoimaa. Ei vero-ohjausta. Pelkällä porkkanalla ja tuella ohjataan tuotantoa. Emme voi suostua suuriin hiilidioksidipäästöihin, koska se syö työpaikkoja. Puun poltto uunissa on energiansäästöä." Ymmärrys ei perustunut fysikaalisen todellisuuden ymmärtämiseen ja aluepolitiikka esitti ilmeisen tärkeää osaa monessa päätöksen perustelussa. Yksipuoleinen ymmärrys eri energiamuotojen hyödyistä ja haistoista, puhumattakaan hinnasta.
    Arvosana: 7-

  • Puolue D: "Hiilidioksidipäästötaso 20% tavoitettavissa helposti, vaihtoehtoisilla energiamuodoilla ja säästöillä. Kyseinen taso täytyy olla minimitaso mihin päästään EU-ehdotuksen mukaisessa ajassa. Lisäydinvoimaa ei tarvita. Verotusohjausta tulee käyttää energiamuotojen tukemisessa. Tuulivoiman hinta ei nouse, kun muiden hinta nousee." Haastava ja kohtuullisen johdonmukainen ehdotuskirjo, mutta perustuen moderniin tietoon eri vaihtoehtojen kustannuksista ja haitoista. Ydinvoiman kieltoperusteluista ei selkeyttä.
    Arvosana: 8

  • Puolue E: "Vaihtoehtoisten polttoaineiden käyttöä pitäisi tukea verotuksella. Verotetaan tuhlausta, palkitaan säästöä. Lisää tuulivoimaa." Kanta hiilidioksidipäästöistä epäselvä, hieman sama kuva ydinvoimasta.
    Arvosana: 7+

  • Puolue F: "Sähkön kulutus tulee kasvamaan lisää, kysyntään pakko vastata. Energiansäästö lisäämällä energiatehokkaan suomalaisen teknologian vientiä [???]" Tätä kuunnellessa teki mieli itkeä. Selitykset olivat luonnonvoimaisia (ei voi vaikuttaa) ja teknologiaongelmiin tarjottiin lisää teknologiaa ratkaisuksi.
    Arvosana: 5
Lukijoille jääköön tehtäväksi päätellä, mikä puolue esitti minkäkin kannan. Lopulta sillä ei ole väliä, koska puolueet eivät omaa niin vahvaa yksimielisyyttä, että kenenkään tahto toteutuisi. Eli jatkamme BUA-linjalla todennäköisesti eteenpäin, ellei radikaali konsesus materialisoidu tyhjästä yllättäen.

Kaikkien puolueiden edustajat saivat miinuksia seuraavasta:
  1. Ei käsitystä öljytuotannon huipusta ja vaikutuksista
  2. Nettoenergialaskelmien puuttuminen perusteluista
  3. Jevonin paradoksin huomiotta jättäminen energiasäästöpuheissa
  4. Ei sanaakaan Venäjän energiatuonnin tai maan maakaasuvarojen riittävyydestä
  5. Ei rohkeutta puhua siitä miten käy, jos emme muuta energia- ja päästörakennett radikaalisti
Aloitus oli kuitenkin hyvä näinkin vaikeaan aiheeseen. Näitä keskusteluja vain tarvittaisiin lisää, mukaan täytyisi saada alan puolueettomat asiantuntijat ja energia-alan lobbaustahojen suorat valheet pitäisi paljastaa heti kättelyssä, jotta ne eivät jää kummittelemaan kansalaisten mieliin. Sitten pitäisi saada fysikaaliseen todellisuuteen perustuva konsensus ja tekoja aikaiseksi.

Puhe ei ratkaise ongelmiamme. Vaalien jälkeinen tilanne näytää, millä puolueilla on tahtoa ja kykyä navigoida vaikeidenkin asioiden kanssa vastustuksen läpi ja saada asioita tapahtumaan.

Olemme energia-asioissa todennäköisesti jo vaiheessa, jossa vain teoilla on merkitystä. Juhlapuheilla ei jätetä itsestä kuin huono poliittinen perintö.

Tuesday, 20 February 2007

"Save" the world & earn $25 mil by fooling everybody

Richard "VirginAir" Branson's recent competition announcement for successful atmospheric carbon capture & storage technology that scales has peppered the discussion again on geo-atmospheric engineering.

This is not the first time these things have been discussed. Some serious climatologist have already suggested that we should consider "dirtying" the atmosphere to ensure that global dimming continues to protect us from further warming of the climate.

So, drastic times call for drastic measures, eh?

Perhaps, but even drastic measures must obey the laws of physics.

Big technological atmospheric geo-engineering attempts have a high likelihood of being not only misguided, but producing the reverse of the desired result.

Let's use the Branson's competition as an example.

What is required to capture C02 from atmosphere and lessen it's impact on global warming?

  1. Extracting CO2 from air takes a non-trivial amount of energy (at scales we are talking about)
  2. Binding this CO2 into a liquid/solid that is environmentally harmless requires some energy (for 1&2 - if it was highly reactive and not inert, it wouldn't stay in the atmosphere, would it?)
  3. Moving this resulting matter into a place where it can be stored and poses no risk of re-release of CO2, is still available for normal earth carbon cycle (i.e. isn't hermeneutically sealed for thousands of years) and is environmentally safe requires A LOT of energy.
1+2+3=lot of energy requirements.

Where does this energy come from?

What is the most abundant, economical & infrastructure ready fuel we have after oil & gas?

Coal.

Which in turn releases CO2 (carbon capture & sequestration is pure "on paper" technology, no plants exist for it).

Somebody has to do the calculations, but if the laws of thermodynamics still apply, this may not be a winning proposition overall. Not in terms of energy use or in terms of CO2 bound.

Now, about "passive" systems - these are more interesting, but...

First of all, passive is a misnomer.
All systems require energy to do their work.
Passive here probably means: a free no man-made external power supply (that must be re-filled) is included.

Second, no energy in earth eco-system if by definition "free". Earth has several mass-energy cycles that keep it in equilibrium. As a thought game, if one were to remove all the energy from winds for example, what do you think would happen to the earth wind/cloud/rain atmospheric cycle? It would cease to exist. And so would life on earth.

So beware of anybody bearing gifts of energy with titles like "free" or "clean" or "harmless" slapped onto them.

Still, educated people say that passive CO2 systems are possible, although the energy calculations they base they thinking on is clearly limited to the chemical bond level only.

This is a classic case of defining the system boundary in an EROI (or here CO2) calculation.

Somebody has to build these systems, somebody has to install them, somebody has to service them and the output (e.g. calcium carbonate) must be moved and stored.

All this requires huge amounts of energy that in turn must be produced (currently using C02 releasing technologies).

So is there another solution out of the dilemma?

Can we fix bad CO2 polluting technologies before we actually come up with a clearly C02 binding (better than C02 neutral) energy technology that scales to world wide production FAST, and not in 50 years?

I think the last bastion of research lies in the field of bio-engineering of bacteria, plankton and enzymes. And biologist know this.

The only way any living system may operate in near equilibrium state is when the feces & trash of some species become the primary fuel of other species, which in turn produce fuel for the first (or third) species.

Currently we are fairly far off from this kind of equilibrium. We are producing way too much CO2 (at an increasing pace) and there is not enough living organisms to scale to meet that output and use it up.
Another way of looking at the C02 emission problem is that we have a massive energy cycle non-equilibrium. The resulting C02 is not being bound and used by other energy binding/releasing mechanisms.
Can we manufacture such a beast at massive scale AND not risk the likelihood of tipping the non-equilibrium towards the reverse trend (too little CO2)?

Or... should we seriously consider alternative approaches to all these first order law defying exercises and concentrate on the processes of allostasis on the global human scale?

If I were Branson, I'd seriously consider hiring a group of guys to do a full value-stream mapping of the whole energy use in the air traffic business and figure way to use X0% less fuel, fly X0% less, use a less carbon intensive alternative for kerosene and capture the C02 out of the fuel used.

That's where I'd put my $25 mil to begin with.

But that wouldn't buy Branson publicity, give him an image of a "nice environmental guy" in the minds of the masses and let everybody think that "this problem is now practically solved, and markets will take care of it."
And most importantly: according to corporate speech, it's not the job of profit making entities to fix the climate. Companies are "beyond morality" and only exist to make profit at maximum levels, by offsetting some of their expenses as externalities to others.
No solution. Case closed?